Or what I saw on my walk this morning
This morning I took advantage of a break in the rain to head out for walk. Not surprisingly, my favorite aspect of this choice of exercise is the opportunity to see what people are up to in their front yards. Of course, most of my energy goes towards mentally redesigning the landscapes I pass by, but I often get ideas that are particularly useful because they are real world examples - not something out of a glossy shelter magazine. So, in the inimitable style of Glamour Magazine's Dos and Don'ts, here are some of my observations:
DO replace lawn with low water plants
A little dated, the phormiums to either side of the pathway have gotten too big, and this garden could use a bit more color contrast, however, this is an excellent example of a low maintenance, no lawn front yard. Scale and balance are first rate, something much more difficult to achieve in lawn-free environment. I sometimes forget the KISS principle - keep it simple, stupid- and this garden is a good reminder for me.
DON'T - create a fortress of green around your home
An oversized, looming wall is always unpleasant to be around - the fact that it's made of plants instead of wood doesn't make it any better. Regardless, Italian cypress is a horrible choice for this sort of thing as it gets way too big, looks shabby up close and can't really be pruned attractively. Leave it where it belongs; punctuating the countryside in France and Italy.
This one looks like some bizarre suburban game of hedge shearing one-upmanship.
DO make it easy to see the path to the front door
Another slightly dated lawnless front, but that just shows the owners were ahead of the curve. The path to the front door is easy to see and not overwhelmed by the plants, an important design objective in the front. Love the red accents.
DON'T make the front door the only feature there is
This much hardscape is expensive! Couldn't a little of the budget been spared for even one plant?
This is actually a charming entry and looks like it was recently done, but the no-plants look should have been a no-go and the funky path needs to be replaced. Although speaking of paths...
...at least there is one! I have the uncomfortable feeling I've somehow walked in on this house before it had time to dress.
FYI, if you're wondering about the black blindfolds, in true Glamour Magazine Dos and Don'ts style, this is my attempt to black out the house's "eyes" to ensure anonymity. And no houses were harmed in the photographing of this post.























I agree with all of your comments about these front yards. The ones without lawns make the others look incredibly boring and as you imply 'naked'. Thanks for taking us on your morning walk!
Thanks, Claire. Seeing the photos right next to each other really drives home just how dull a giant square of grass is.
Posted by: Claire | February 26, 2009 at 06:36 PM
May be later into spring there'll be more colors. BTW, I love the black blindfolds.
Hi Blossom - I was wondering about that myself. There didn't seem to be much room left for seasonal color, but I think this garden may have had more nooks and cranies than I noticed, so I might be in for a surprise in a few months.
Glad you enjoyed the blindfolds; they made me laugh when I was pasting them in.
Posted by: blossom | February 26, 2009 at 06:57 PM
I like your Dos and Donts! I have thought about doing something similar in my blog as well. Good design/Bad design. I'm also a huge fan of phormium!
Hi Pam - Everyone loves a dos and don'ts or before and after style post so blog away! Always fun to take a peek at what others are doing in their gardens.
I use phormiums all the time, but so many of the cultivars revert or are newer introductions and their stated growth turns out to be grossly understated that I'm trying to wean myself off of them. Bronze Baby, Jester and Guardsman are probably my favorites, although I've started using Dark Delight now that it seems to be more available.
Posted by: Pam Kersting | February 26, 2009 at 06:59 PM
I do the same thing when out for walks with one of my friends as we discuss what we would do differently. I agree with what you pointed out. Love the comment about hedge shearing one -upmanship.
I'm trying to convince my husband to remove most of our front lawn. I'd rather spend time on gardens than mowing, edging, etc.
Hi Catherine! I know it's a cliche, but men are generally very attached to their lawns and their barbecues. I've said before that I have no lawn, but the reality is I still have one miniscule patch that is always half gone by the end of the summer due to lack of sun. This winter I've finally convinced my husband that it's time to replace it, so there's hope for you yet!
Posted by: Catherine | February 26, 2009 at 07:17 PM
I was thinking what to do with our lawn that got ugly during winter. Yellow and bold spots and moss, moss, moss. You made me think about putting some plants. But it's a big lawn. Should I start from one section and move step by step? Thanks for your post!
Tatyana, Town Mouse is right that irrigating a lawn is done completely differently than other plants and also needs to be more precise or you get a lot of wasted water and/or dead lawn patches. But that is here in California, irrigating might be different if you live in a wetter climate. If you have a large lawn you could probably do it in stages, as long as you took out the lawn in fairly large chunks. Generally speaking, lawn becomes difficult to irrigate efficiently when any portion of it is less than 8' across, which blows, because I love doing little snakey things with lawns when the opportunity arises. You can also use grid-style micro-irrigation such as Netafim for smaller patches of lawns, but that becomes a much bigger project and requires more expertise, so I wouldn't recommend it.
Love that this post is inspiring you to do a little experimenting in your own garden!
Posted by: Tatyana | February 26, 2009 at 08:32 PM
Oh, don't get me started with the green fortress approach... Very popular right now, it seems.
Tatyana, when I removed my lawn, I just had it taken out all at once. Irrigation gets really complicated otherwise. Here's one great post:
http://montanawildlifegardener.blogspot.com/2009/02/how-to-remove-lawn.html.
I'm sure garden chick will have more.
Great answer T.Mouse. Do I owe you a commission on this one?
Posted by: Renate (Town Mouse) | February 26, 2009 at 08:53 PM
Great post. I often find myself examining yards for things I like/dislike. This was fun to see. And quite helpful!
Hi Melanthia. I think this is a habit most of us gardeners have in common. I stick to mental (or in this case blog) critiques, but I have friends who travel with shears or scissors so they can stealthily sneak cuttings from front gardens when a likely specimen presents itself.
Posted by: Melanthia | February 26, 2009 at 09:56 PM
Hi Susan
Great post.
That hedge 'one upmanship' pic- ha, ha, ha. They really are into 'call that a hedge' mode or do they totally NOT get on. I mean, eliminating any possibilty of seeing each other.
Thanks
Rob
I have this mental image of the first neighbor growing a 3' hedge, then the second growing his to 5' and so on and so on until one of them finally just conceded the battle.
Posted by: rob (our french garden) | February 27, 2009 at 12:30 AM
Great Dos and Don'ts here. You are funny, I'm sure no one will recognize these homes.
Hi Darla. I think you're right. Even if they did, would they ask me to take it down, or just write an angry comment defending their right to turn their front yard into an homage to turfgrass?
Posted by: Darla | February 27, 2009 at 05:42 AM
Very good examples. I think whether the houses you showcased are outdated or not is not a factor, I love them both. I am guilty of a green fortress, but sometimes it is necessary, at least in my view. Sure looks good from inside though. This is an excellent post.
They mainly seem outdated to me because of the way the plants are cared for, i.e. pollarded trees and ruthlessly sheared hedges, plus the general lack of foliage plants. I'm not against hedges, just ones that replace the idea of a fence rather than enhance it. Both of these hedges are way too high, and meet the ground at a perfect 90 degree angle with no medium or small shrubs or plants to break the hard angle. You'd be surprised how often clients ask for a vine suggestion during an intial consultation that will soften their fence, but haven't even considered increasing the size of their planting beds. If all you're doing is replacing a brown fence with a green one, how much difference does that really make?
A new idea suggested to me by my designer friend Patricia St John I've been playing with is replacing a rigid hedge with one made up of Miscanthus transmorrisonensis, Evergreen Miscanthus.
Posted by: tina | February 27, 2009 at 06:45 AM
First, I loved the blackout lines! When I walk with my husband, I point out garden do's and don't's while he examines the cars parked in the driveway. It's so funny how we notice different things based on our interests. I do think some lawn in the front can help a home fit in better with the rest of the neighborhood, but you're probably thinking that the whole neighborhood should just get rid of their lawns! And overgrown shrubs/hedges are unsightly. I bet many owners don't like them but just haven't had the necessary umph to tackle the big project of removing them and figuring out what to plant instead. - VW
VW, I don't actually think everyone should get rid of their lawn and I agree that radically departing from the neighborhood's style can be a little glaring - although someone always has to be the first to display a new idea. What is interesting about these photos is that they are all from the very same short stretch of street. Everyone either has no lawn (I chose the best examples, there were some white gravel/juniper disasters) or lawn with almost no plants. There didn't seem to be any middle ground.
Posted by: VW | February 27, 2009 at 10:52 AM
Perfect "garden chick" combo of insight and wit!
DP, stop, you're making me blush! (I'm just saying that to sound humble, I love compliments, keep 'em coming.)
Posted by: DaffodilPlanter | February 27, 2009 at 12:39 PM
I love the advice. And can now tell my husband, "see, we're supposed to have a front walkway!"
But don't tell him you read this on a blog. Tell him you consulted with a very exclusive designer so you bring some real clout to the discussion!
Posted by: Katie | February 28, 2009 at 04:49 PM
I am glad no garden design photographers were harmed in the making of this post.
I didn't even get any dirty looks! A successful venture, all the way around.
Posted by: wayne | March 01, 2009 at 06:09 AM
Fun post! I do like the bravery of that first house you show, and I agree the phormiums are getting out of hand. The spikey form is one of my favorites, and I'm glad more plants like it are coming on the scene. Dianellas seem to be a good introduction in plants shaped like this, though their colors seem limited to the blue-green end of the color scale. But the ones I've planted (D. revoluta 'Baby Bliss') so far haven't grown larger than advertised.
My street is a little on the busy size, and one entire side of it seems to be developing the fortress effect, with fences over the 3-foot code height and hedges doing worse things. Maybe people need to be reminded of the statistic that a house with a visible front door is a safer one, but folks seem to want to make their home look like some impenetrable castle.
James, I'm with you on the spikey plants, to the point where I wind up with too many in a design and have to edit backwards. Don't use dianellas much, but am working on two planting plans right now so may give them a try.
Posted by: lostlandscape | March 01, 2009 at 07:32 PM
It's funny how so many people find plants a burden, and think lawns are low maintenance. Good examples and a good punch :-)
Camellia, you're exactly right!
Posted by: Camellia | March 02, 2009 at 03:26 AM
LOL...I love the blacked out eyes!
Since my front yard is a pasture I guess I don't have to worry about making you list!
I like the 5th picture...if I was to have a front yard, I would have no grass and would probably plant tomatoes or something. Thus the reason I don't have a front yard...yet!
Love your design insights! Kim
Posted by: inadvertentfarmer | March 04, 2009 at 08:54 AM
A very interesting post! I do that too, on my walks... the urge to make over is hard to resist!
Now I'm thinking that the phormiums on either side of my front yard should be taken out... they've been bugging me for a while... i need you to walk by my house!
Posted by: Anne | March 18, 2009 at 02:26 PM