After a grueling day at the drawing board and computer working on my current designs (or as I like to think of it, making the world a safer place for bees and butterflies), I decided to wrap things up by visiting some of my favorite garden blogs. As I browsed new posts and comment pages, I couldn't help noticing that I was seeing a lot of the same commenters on every site, and furthermore, that many of them joined Blotanical in the past several months, just as I have myself. And I started wondering, have I wound up in a blogging clique?
For those of you who aren't familiar with it, Blotanical is a wonderful garden blog directory listing over 1000 blogs. It has nifty features like the ability to click on a map of the world to find bloggers who live close to you - helpful if you want to read about gardening strategies that match your climate or conversely, if you want to read what gardeners are up to in more exotic locales. Beyond that, though, Blotanical is a social networking site, with the opportunity to friend (or fav) other bloggers and blogs, cast votes for current blog posts (and here's some of the high school part) receive both a personal ranking and blog ranking based on how active you are and how popular your blog is.
Blotanical vs. High School - My Observations:
Blotanical: People who join about the same time tend to visit each other's blogs and vote for each other.
High School: Freshman class bonds over their shared newbie experience - although fortunately no wedgies are involved at Blotanical.
Blotanical: More experienced bloggers have much more popular blogs, but many are kind about reaching out to newer bloggers to make them feel welcome.
High School: Seniors who want to pad their college resumes may agree to tutor freshmen.
Blotanical: You tell yourself being popular and climbing up in the rankings doesn't matter, but then your numbers move and you're secretly thrilled.
High School: You tell yourself going to the dance is no big deal, but then you get invited and you're secretly thrilled.
And here I am writing what could only be considered an "insider's" post - what could be more high school than that?
Just for the record, anyone who reads my blog is welcome to join my clique. I would even give you a cool nickname, if you all didn't have one already.

















SO true! Blotanical is essential to finding out who else is out there, and staying in touch. I think the founder, Stuart Robinson from Oz, must be our Student Body President?
The high school metaphor is right on. The cool girls from the senior class have indeed been kind in deigning to chat to freshmen like me.
My neighborhood bloggers are the kids who ride the school bus together and we stay in touch even though we might have different interests (Bamboo Geek) or are in different classes (The Blogging Nurseryman is definitely a cool senior guy).
Then there are the girls with an attitude that I get to hang with during lunch (Garden Chick, VW, the Mice).
To say nothing of the exchange students who have exotic experiences to report (Shirl in Scotland).
And in lieu of asking you all to sign my yearbook, you are either on my FAve list at Blotanical, or on the Blogroll on my site.
Now I have to go fix my makeup before home room!
Posted by: DaffodilPlanter | February 19, 2009 at 10:54 AM
Cutest Couple: Chris and Katie at Garden Punks
Posted by: DaffodilPlanter | February 19, 2009 at 07:09 PM
Well there is a Claire in 'The Breakfast Club' and you know what they say about her name....
Posted by: Claire | February 19, 2009 at 08:34 PM
Anthony Michael Hall, skinny geek, I take that as a compliment and a pretty accurate description of me, if I was ever cast in Breakfast Club.
Thanks Daffodil.
Your blogger bud,
Bamboo Geek
Posted by: Bamboo Geek | February 19, 2009 at 08:42 PM
I joined blotanical at a time when I had lots of freetime, now I don't have the time for all the cool blogs I found. so I am trying to focus and do some random exploring at blotanical and there are days I do no garden blogging at all. I am glad we hooked up when I had the time to make lots of friends
Posted by: wayne | February 20, 2009 at 03:24 AM
Hello all - So I almost used a photo from the movie Mean Girls since it's a more current reference, but I can see I made the right choice with Breakfast Club!
DP - your comment cracked me up! But I think we need to make Stuart the principal - he has too much power to be a mere student body pres.
Claire - your comment is thoroughly intriguing...what do they say about the name Claire?
Bamboo Geek - thanks for the visit! I can see by both your name and your comment that you've mastered the art of "Geek Chic."
Wayne - I hear you. I also had more time for blogging and blotanical in January and am having to manage my time more wisely. But don't drop me completely! I'd miss both your humor and your take on garden design.
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | February 20, 2009 at 08:58 AM
Hi Susan, I like your 'attitude'! I kind of noticed you had a little one early on...but attitude is a cool thing girl:)
I have already spoken to my husband about this very thing. Some other Blot. members and I have secretly discussed this as well...on our plots and in emails. I'm probably a good 20 yrs older than you (?) I'll be 52--but yes, I felt that cliquish thing not long after I started getting the faves. In fact, I likend it more to MIDDLE SCHOOL than high school, but that's because I guess my h.s. years were easier for me than m.s.
I just started at Blot. in late Nov. At first it was just 'fun'. Then, I got some faves. I don't know what happened but as I'd write posts, I'd get lots of picks. I picked back. Yes, it became an obsession for a while. I saw my numbers move and it was exactly as you wrote! I wanted more...I wanted to be 'popular'--eek. Why? I'm a mental health counselor!!!
Then, I noticed that some of the 'cool' girls wouldn't talk to me. They still haven't talked to me!! But to overcome that insecurity--which I felt all through middle school--I started 'talking' to the 'less popuular' kids in school. I smiled at them and they liked me. Wow, I got 'cool' by being friends with kids who weren't cool! Suddenly, I was becoming really popular. And now, I have no idea why it even matters. My 'less popular' friends are moving up, too...and they are some of the NICEST people because they didn't shun me like some of the 'oldies' did:) In fact, I am acting like I did in h.s. I guess, because I moved in h.s. and didn't fit in w/the 'cool' clique and had to be friends with EVERYONE. I was a person who got along w/everyone. I guess I still am, because I HATE Cliques!!! I don't play cliquish games. I just try to accept everyone and help others however I can. I guess that's ok, right? In fact, the more I think about it, that's how I've been all my life, and it's worked out well. Here I am at 52 and I've seen a parallel to real life. It may be self-serving in some ways (because it does make me feel 'good' to be 'liked' !!) but, I also like to make others feel good and don't intentionally seek popularity.
WOW. How's that for an analysis??!!! You're right about it all...and I've thought about quitting blotanical as recently as today!! I haven't been active there in a couple of days. I have met some great people though, so I just can't walk away--can I? Should I? That remains to be seen....Meanwhile, the saga continues...:)
Posted by: Jan(ThanksFor2Day) | February 20, 2009 at 09:43 AM
Goodness me, It's all going on over here!
Posted by: rob (our french garden) | February 20, 2009 at 02:25 PM
And you didn't even mention the Favorites and Favorite bloggers feature. Kind of like your clique. My favorites are bloggers in my geographical area and with similar interests (natives, wildlife gardens) and can quickly see who of them has something new to show. I'm sure the vegetable gardeners do the same thing with each other. It's just so convenient...
On the flip side, there's a slight temptation to veer away from one's blog's mission by doing a Beautiful Post with Photos and Poems to become more popular. As Jan says, the saga continues...
Posted by: Renate (Town Mouse) | February 20, 2009 at 03:18 PM
DP - so I have attitude? Love it! Like, I can picture myself sitting around a cafeteria table with, like, a bunch of garden bloggers, giggling our heads off.
Blotanical is funny. The faving seems kind of juvenile, but I really like it that I can conveniently catch up on the blogs I'm interested in via my 'faved blog posts' list. The picking for points thing is kind of funny, too, but I can understand how it helps Blotanical function by encouraging people to note which posts they like. And you shouldn't trust my picks to be fabulous posts as I generally pick all the posts of people I like, regardless of how great they are. Hey - I get points for it! Though sometimes I just click on new posts through my blog sidebar and don't have the opportunity to pick.
Anyway, Susan, your thoughts are in line with mine on the subject. I do like to be ranked closer to the top than the bottom, but realize how silly it is. Sometimes silly is, like, fun, though! VW
Posted by: VW | February 20, 2009 at 06:48 PM
Thanks for communicating by email, Susan. Now that I've been here a couple of times, I'm finding that I actually like your posts and may just 'have' to put you on my followers list:) And it's not so you'll like me!! Also, if you lived closer, I would definitely have you do a consult for me: my yard needs help!!!!!
Posted by: Jan(ThanksFor2Day) | February 20, 2009 at 08:41 PM
That's exactly right! Blotanical definitely has its similarities to High School, but like High School, once you get past all the teenage stuff - its a great tool to get to meet and read about people with similar interests, that would have taken me a lot longer to find by myself.
My curiosity is piqued... what do they say about Claire's name?
Posted by: Ross | February 21, 2009 at 07:26 AM
Town Mouse - when I signed up for Blotanical in December, it didn't really occur to me to search for local blogs. I was lucky that so many bloggers like you Mice and Lost in the Landscape and others found me because it is particularly nice to share gardening and design experiences with those who are more local. On the other hand, I feel like I have almost as much in common with Australian and South African gardeners and the many posts about the cold weather from other bloggers is a reminder of how lucky we have it here.
Jan, the first time I read your comment, this is what I got out of it "blah,blah,blah I think Susan is only around 32 years old." Naturally this made me want to read it again! Your comments are a good example of how even though gardening is the obvious thing we have in common, other aspects of ourselves (in your case, your counseling background) allow us to offer fresh perspectives.
Yes Rob, as always it's nuts around here, or bonkers or...well the only phrase I remember from French class is "la plume de ma tante est sur la table" so can't be fully international in my response.
VW, like, OMG, of course DP recognized how rockin' we are! I mean, like, only totally cool peeps like us don't bother getting dressed until the afternoon 'cuz we're still blogging about totally cool topics like allergies and pollen!
Ross, I also want the answer to the Claire naming mystery. If she doesn't respond, I'm heading over to her blog and commandeering her comments page in an effort to get closure.
And to everyone, I didn't even know there was a section that ranks blogs based on how many hits they have until I logged on briefly yesterday. And yes, I told myself it doesn't matter right before I scrolled obsessively through the pages until I found out where I ranked (57 for any inquiring minds that want to know).
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | February 21, 2009 at 08:44 AM
This post is great, as are the comments. I wandered over here after seeing you on my Graduated Gardening blog. Your blog is "cool" to use a ubiquitous term from way back when. I have to say, the What Not to Wear pic really had me hooked because I love that show. Anyway, thanks for the visit and see you around!
Posted by: Melanthia | February 23, 2009 at 04:00 PM
A daring post ;-). When I joined Blotanical, I was overwhelmed by all the 'oldies'' lovely welcoming words, made me feel very special...until I realised that some of them put excactly the same welcome message to absolutely everyone newbie, ...with a little hint after the welcome to visit their plot. So, I think point hunters come in all categories :-). Instead of faving, which sort of comes with a 'valuation', and probably a disappointment for the ones who aren't (or aren't by the 'right' blotanist), why can't it be possible just to 'bookmark'? And all these 'top posts', 'blotanist of the year' etc. Why make a competition of it all? That's not why we're blogging, is it?
Posted by: Camellia | February 24, 2009 at 05:48 AM
No, Camellia, it is not why we are blogging. Which I think was the point, and a funny point at that. And its like, here we all are serious and committed and oh so very mature (blah, blah). But suddenly somebody starts talking about "popularity points" and at least a part of us all reverts to....(shudder, moan)...HIGH SCHOOL. Or in one case even Middle School...which is really a nasty memory to call up.
We are still the same people we always have been. The difference is that we do not react, and even to our own selves, the way we did in those "thrilling days of yesteryear".
I remember walking to High School near the end of my senior year with one of the school secretaries who happened to live in our neighborhood and was a pal of my mom. And she said, " Well, these are your golden years and they are almost over". And I (rightly) thought, "Oh, I SOOOO hope not and that it gets way better than this!.
And of course it did, and I got way better than I was then too...at least I hope so. Which is why...since my story is not at all unique...we can all laugh at ourselves and with each other about the "popularity bomb". It still can explode enough to catch our attention and give us a little kick when it drops a few rosebuds.
Hey, I love to be loved! The reasons do not have to be serious. Since you all do as well, consider that I just dumped a bushel of rose petals over your heads.
I will write a serious garden involved message next time. Love you guys by the way.
Posted by: Ninja Granny | February 24, 2009 at 06:14 PM
Melanthia - thanks for the visit. I wandered off the topic of gardening more than a bit on this one, but isn't that what makes blogging fun?
Camellia and NG - If I've learned one thing from this post, it's that we all have something to say on the subject of high school!
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | February 26, 2009 at 08:29 AM
Uh oh, I might be one of the "seniors" from Blotanical who joined up at the very beginning. I've been remiss in not stopping over there to find new blogs. I rarely pick, but if someone new does happen to comment on my blog I try to go to their blog and read it and make a relevant comment.
If I find a blog that looks pretty good, I'll add it to my feed reader and follow it for awhile.
Carol, May Dreams Gardens
Posted by: Carol, May Dreams Gardens | March 09, 2009 at 04:15 PM
I had the same thought as Carol! I'm probably an "oldie" (ugh, hate THAT term) from Blotanical. In fact, I was one of Stuart's beta testers before he took it online.
I like to use Blotanical to check for new local bloggers, and I try to check in regularly for messages, but I don't use it to find new blogs. I just don't have the time. To address the complaints of some of your commenters, I think the best way to reach out to an "oldie" is to visit and comment on his or her blog from time to time. Remember that they're probably following the feeds of 50 to 100 blogs because they've been at it a while. They may be trying to comment on those blogs regularly, write their own posts, keep up with their day jobs, say hi to their kids and spouse occasionally. Not necessarily in that order, but maybe. ;-) Be patient.
This is a great community of fellow garden lovers, and I can't imagine anyone intentionally shunning anyone else. People are just busy. :-)
Posted by: Pam/Digging | March 23, 2009 at 10:49 AM
Oldie does have a certain negative ring to it! HA Blotanical is a great resource to find garden bloggers. Just a few years ago there were hardly any, and it was hard to find them. Now you can look at the maps and visit whomever you are interested in. The popularity things are just a way Stuart gets more visits to his site. It works, too. :-)
Frances
Posted by: Frances | March 24, 2009 at 02:04 PM
Carol, Pam and Frances -
I feel compelled to point out that I used the phrase "more experienced bloggers" - NOT old, oldie or senior! :-)
I wrote this post just to have some fun, and it's interesting to see the wide range of responses. The truth is, I don't think Blotanical is anything like high school, or at least, the social acceptance and popularity aspect of it. If you write a blog, you want others to read it, or why bother? As Frances notes, the whole process of picking and faving does indeed bring people to your site. Wehther or not they stick around is up to them.
Having said that, maybe it's a little like high school, as I am rather flattered some of the cool kids dropped by to comment!
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | March 24, 2009 at 02:23 PM
Hi Susan, you have indeed had some fun here, and stirred up old memories from high school, or worse, middle school. It is funny to me to be considered cool. My niche in school was to make snide remarks about the cool kids to get a laugh. :-)
Frances
Posted by: Frances | March 24, 2009 at 02:57 PM