Mostly that I can be pretty sloppy if I'm not being graded.
But wait, I'm skipping to the end.
Yesterday afternoon I spent some time cleaning and organizing my office. In the process, I found myself paging through the seven years of design journals I've kept since my very first semester of Landscape Graphics I in design school. Our instructor required us to keep a journal and we did regular sketching exercises - both on site and at home. Here is some homework from my first graphics class:
The assignment was to illustrate how gardens invite people in. I went to a local park and sketched different ways a park might welcome visitors (apparently I included not only adults and children in this assignment, but ducks as well - I've always been very PC).
Not homework, just killing time waiting for Plant ID class to start at Strybing Arboretum in San Francisco. I was actually drawing for fun, not for any specific reason. Boy, are those days gone!
Here was the class's final graphics assignment - make sketches of the Sunnyside Conservatory in San Francisco and then do a black and white 24x36 illustration.
I sketched this standing on the sidewalk (30 minutes)
and then drafted and illustrated the design (something like a million hours).
Overal, not too shabby for a first year design student with no particular art training.
Next semester's Landscape Graphics II instructor was the opposite of LG I's, he despised pencils and only drafted in pen. So, being the suck-upy little teacher's pet that I am, I of course swtiched to ink.

Here are plant vignettes I saw at a nursery. Only one semester later and already I'm abandoning detail for speed.
Fast forward to my first year as a designer. Still sketching, but you can see the technique is sloppier.
I later did an illustrated sketch of this one. (Why did I make a dry creek bed blue? At least it's pretty.)
and just for fun, here is how it actually turned out (we kept the dry creek bed , but nixed the upper patio).
Last year's journal was virtually sketch-free, mostly this type of quick birds eye views to show layout options.
Here's just about the only sketch I could find from the last several months.
I drew it, and I'm not even sure I understand it! I think it's a fountain built into a hillside with a winding staircase and plants behind it. I particularly like the well-drawn patio table you can barely make out in the front - an oval with two lines attached.
So am I the only one who finds herself chosing speed over precision, practicality over perfection? Drawing and rendering don't apply to every profession, but don't we all have areas in our jobs and careers where we find ourselves relying on our experience at the expense of reaching out for new ideas?
In this economy, I'm more aware than ever that time is money, but I'm wondering if I should return to spending more time on the artistic expression of design. I know these are drawings, not actual gardens, but I've always spent time rendering for myself as much as the client - unlike some designers and gardeners, my ideas flow best through my pen.
I think I'll head outside and do some sketching.

























Beautiful sketches. You are a very good artist.
Posted by: tina | March 05, 2009 at 05:38 PM
I enjoyed seeing what goes on in a designer's brain and sketchbook! You're lucky to have a gift with the sketching pen as well as writing pen.
Posted by: DaffodilPlanter | March 05, 2009 at 05:47 PM
I think all your sketches are very good.
I find that I rush through a lot lately. I have a 2 year old and so I definitely have to move quick. I write lists to help keep myself organized and then have no idea what I wrote or what it meant.
Posted by: Catherine | March 05, 2009 at 07:17 PM
I know the feeling - I don't know when the last time was that I just sketched just for fun?
I think I would be too embarrassed to open my earlier sketches up for public consumption...
I find that ideas flow a lot better when they are first drawn by hand, and then I can neaten them up using software - maybe thats a cheat?
Posted by: Ross | March 05, 2009 at 11:54 PM
Hi Susan
Well there's no doubting your artistic credentials. So I'm guessing that with experience things come together instinctively hence quicker 'brushstroke' sketches.
As you put it, ideas flow through your pen so why not return to more of the artistic expression of design?
Rob
Posted by: rob (our french garden) | March 06, 2009 at 12:32 AM
Wow .. I wish I went to a garden designing class. Love those sketches and drawings.
Posted by: blossom | March 06, 2009 at 07:12 AM
Hey, just stopping by to say I enjoyed this post. (everything is leafing out here! awaiting the freesias.... so I can bring that scent indoors )
Posted by: Alice Joyce | March 06, 2009 at 08:19 AM
I'm definitely impressed with those beautiful sketches. My mother took me to a drawing teacher for a few months in elementary school, then gave up when it was apparent that no drawing talent lurked inside my hands. Thank goodness for graph paper and circular cutouts for bird-eye views! You really should keep sketching. Maybe you could mat some of them to hang on your office walls. VW
Posted by: VW | March 06, 2009 at 11:09 AM
Oh, I already feel embarrassed about my limited photography skills. Sketching seems like just a faraway dream. Maybe when I retire. Of course there are many other areas in my life where I'm choosing speed over precision, quality, beauty. Cooking comes to mind. And when I catch myself, I'm usually glad I did and try to slow down.
Posted by: Renate (Town Mouse) | March 06, 2009 at 02:47 PM
For all of you who said such nice things about my sketches, thank you! And, I'm a bit embarrassed as I wasn't intending to show off. When I got distracted from my office cleaning and started paging through all the journals, I was mainly struck by how pretty and thoughtful the first ones are, and how they gradually descend into a mishmash of half-drawn thoughts and obscure notes.
Catherine, a two year old is a good excuse for rushing through more than just sketching!
Ross, I'm just like you - sketch first, than scan it into the computer to make the final plan. I was slow to embrace the computer and have only been using it consistently for about a year, although now I couldn't imagine going back to hand drafting - although I still hand color concept plans. And I'm laughing that after seeing my stuff you'd hesitate to open your sketch book to the world. Did you see the last sketch I showed? I've got plenty of sketches in my journal that look less like charming landscapes and more like the stick figure in a game of hangman.
For those of you wishing you were better artists, I hated art class when I was young - being told how to draw took all the fun out of it. It wasn't until going back to school as an adult and being told what to draw but not how to draw it that I finally started enjoying myself. It's like any skill, practice makes perfect, and the less I draw the less I am able to.
Renate, my photography skills are also lacking and not likely to get better. I get very impatient taking pictures. Isn't it interesting the things we are willing to put time into and the things we just don't want to bother with?
VW, at some point I hope you're going to post some of your designs on your blog!
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | March 06, 2009 at 04:46 PM
Thank you for sharing both the drawings and the history.
Drawing is a way of visual thinking. As one matures you spend more time thinking through all the aspects of a project, creating thumbnails rather than careful renderings.
but you are right in that there needs to be down time to just draw for the pleasure (instead of the profit).
Posted by: Patrick Gracewood | March 06, 2009 at 10:36 PM
It's nice to see your hand drawings. I don't do nearly enough of that these days!
Posted by: Pam Kersting | March 07, 2009 at 05:51 PM
very cool. I once documented the steps I did in making a stained glass piece which this all reminded me about. Because first I thought... "hmmm, if I took a design class would I end up with stained glass pieces," then I thought "how cool she is showing a process here", then it all came together...
Posted by: wayne | March 08, 2009 at 05:53 AM
Patrick, thanks for stopping by. You have a true artist's perspective. Some garden designers I know take a strongly artistic approach to the design process, but others who come to the profession through a love of plants spend very little time on sketching and overall design and most of their time working with the plants. Interesting to see how the link between art and craft is interpreted.
Pam, my point exactly! Drawing is one of the easiest things to give up and before you know it, your skills are so rusty that when you try to draw an idea trapped in your head, it starts to feel like a foreign process.
Wayne, loved looking at your stained glass creative process! I have frequently thought about documenting a design/install process from the original meeting, through site anaysis, concepts final plans and construction, but I'm such an indifferent photographer, I've never quite managed. Looking at your flickr photos is giving me second thoughts.
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | March 08, 2009 at 01:48 PM
Susan--- I was glad I did it once, but I wouldn't want to document every piece I do.
Posted by: wayne | March 09, 2009 at 03:27 PM
I always used to sketch out my clothing designs before hand and then find the fabric that fit with the sketch. Now I fall in love with a fabric and just start cutting and sewing.
My designs now have more of a carefree and whimsical feel to them, where as before they were very well put together creations with hats and matching purses.
I must say I love the new styles better, they are more natural and wearable.
So I say 'yeah' for sloppy!
My garden is much the same...although a little more forethough would be nice. I'm working on it!
LOVE your sketches!
Posted by: inadvertent farmer | March 09, 2009 at 05:37 PM
The perfect is the enemy of the good, it's said. So I think it makes sense that, now that you're out there in the real world, designing for clients rather than teachers, you've abandoned trying to make perfect sketches and instead make less-detailed but quicker drawings.
I've just found your blog and am enjoying your design tips as well as your sense of humor. Good stuff!
Posted by: Pam/Digging | March 23, 2009 at 10:32 AM