While reading the Sunday Wall Street Journal yesterday, I was intrigued by a topic that came up in the Yoder and Son column. It referenced an article written by Prof. Barry Schwartz entitled “The Tyranny of Choice.”
The gist of the article is that most of us fall into a spectrum between maximizers (those who strive to make the best possible choice) and satisficers (those who aim for good enough, despite recognizing that better choices might exist). Interestingly, the article goes on to suggest that despite the extra worry and effort, maximizers tend to be less happy with their choices as exploring so many options leaves them with more opportunity for regret.
Without a doubt I am a satisficer. I never ponder options for long and usually go with my first choice – and I’m talking big ticket items here like houses, cars, career changes and husbands. Recently a Cheesecake Factory opened up nearby but I’ll never eat there – can’t stand the thought of all those menu choices.
Conversely my husband Nick is a classic maximizer. As you can imagine, we are not very compatible shoppers. My idea of purchasing a new household item, say a vacuum, involves looking at the Sunday ad inserts, choosing a store, going to said store, and pretty much walking out with a vacuum. I would be home and happily vacuuming (well, maybe not happily) before Nick had even finished comparing on-line reviews, let alone crafted a comparison spreadsheet with a price vs. quality matrix. And I agree with the premise that satisficers are generally happier with their decisions, as I rarely experience doubts, while Nick is a regular in the return line.
Nick's idea of the right way to begin a shopping trip.
Susan's idea.
Why then, when it comes to gardening, do I turn into a maximizer? I agonize for weeks or even months over a tree choice, and even so have still replaced several within the first year. Every time I come up with a particularly pleasing plant combination for a client, I immediately want to go home and rip something out to make room for what I am sure is a plant combo I will like better. Regardless of time spent planning and choosing, I can’t stop wondering if a better option exists.
So for all your armchair psychologists out there, I’m looking for your insight. Do you think it has something to do with the fact that I am a garden designer by trade? Or do all serious gardeners slip into maximizer mode when it comes to choosing plants? Certainly much of the population does not think this way, as I’ve gone on many garden consultations where someone has recently moved and wants to basically recreate their garden from the last house. Can you imagine? All those options, yet no qualms about sticking to the known.
Maximzer or Satisficer – which are you?


















Having made a trip to Annie's Annuals a year ago, accompanied by a certain garden chick, in which I designed my own front garden in my head, grabbed all the plants I thought would look good and flung them into the ground the next day, I am a classic Garden Satisficer. C'mon, WSJ, can't you come up with something a bit more appealing for us easily pleased cynics?
Why cynics? Well in my case, I shop it fast because I *know* I'm going to change it, and if I'm in a good place emotionally, i.e., feeling pretty happy and confident, I'll enjoy the process of eventually ripping it all out and starting again. Why go through all that trouble when you know that no matter how hard you try, something better will always come along? Maybe that's not cynicism, but the ultimate optimism, who knows? The trick is not to care and just go along for the ride.
Nevertheless, I am totally in love with how my little front garden looks right now, and that serendipitous (How about Serendipitors?) shopping trip/planting design process gave me enormous satisfaction, particularly considering that I had no time to do it any other way.
When I imagined my life while drifting toward my career in garden design, I thought I would spend pleasant hours poring over beautifully colored planting plans at my drafting table with a cup of Earl Grey at hand and YoYo Ma wafting through the breezy sunlight of my serene studio. I suppose this is still my fantasy because it has never, ever happened that way.
I make my garden choices for myself with little pondering of alternatives. However, I do procrastinate until the last minute- not because I am exploring every option, but because I am dealing with some other ADD-induced wild ride I've gotten myself hitched upon.
If one is able to embrace the impermanence and dynamic nature of gardens, one can become Serendipitor.
Posted by: Plantanista | April 27, 2009 at 07:18 PM
Plantanista, I am pleased to hear your trip to Annie's Annuals was such a success, as at least half the plants I filled my little red wagon with from the same shopping trip have expired!
I'm visiting a client later today whose garden whose year old garden has really taken a beating from gophers and deer. I think I will quote your "impermanence and dynamic" comment and see if it cheers her up!
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | April 28, 2009 at 08:44 AM
This may be one of the "compared to whom" questions. Compared to Mr. Mouse, I'm impulsive to the max, but compared to some others, I'm probably a Maximizer.
Maybe you're just doing what makes sense, after all, how big is the difference between vacuum cleaners? But there's a big difference between Dicentra formosa and Eschscholzia californica, or between a redwood and an oak.
Posted by: Town Mouse | April 28, 2009 at 09:26 AM
You described, to a T, the decision-making habits of myself and my husband. Like you and yours, I'm the satisficer and he's the maximizer. It drives me insane to have to buy something with him, so we usually divvy up the responsibilities. I buy furniture, art, and other household decor. He buys electronics, which he cares more about than I do.
I have to say that in the garden I'm still a satisficer. Like your first commenter, I also frequently rip out and change the garden around---not due to regret, but just to explore other options and give new favorite plants a try. I love redesigning!
Posted by: Pam/Digging (Austin) | April 28, 2009 at 09:57 AM
First of all, there are big differences in vacuum cleaners, especially for allergy sufferers :-) I got onto the consumer reports website to find the best choice that fit within our budget. But I wouldn't have spent hours researching a vacuum, so thank goodness for consumer reports. I do enjoy hours spent researching plants. And I totally worry about my tree choices. I do not go to 5 stores to grocery shop and get the very best prices, though, as that's way too much work for me. So maybe I am a maximizer when I enjoy the research (ie on plants) but a satisfier for more boring/time consuming things.
Interesting ideas, I'll have to think about this a bit more!
Posted by: VW | April 28, 2009 at 10:45 AM
Hello Susan
I'd consider myself a satisficer as a rule but find other influences create the maximiser in me.
If I became particularly deficient of much sensory apparatus then I'd never have a maximiser moment:) at least I think, best I just check that...
Rob
Posted by: Rob(ourfrenchgarden) | April 28, 2009 at 01:28 PM
Susan - exactly how many husbands have you purchased? Is there some part of your murky past you'd like to share with me?
Posted by: Nick (Husband # ???) | April 28, 2009 at 02:15 PM
Ah, HE speaks at last! Now we know that Garden Chick didn't just make him up.
I'm with you Nick--except my research lists are in pencil on legal pads, not on spreadsheets.
Posted by: DaffodilPlanter | April 28, 2009 at 03:20 PM
Town Mouse - that's what I like about you, there's never any question that gardens and plants will always be towards the top of your list in importance.
Pam, the arrangement you and your husband operate with sounds similar to ours and we also often choose the divide and conquer strategy.
Way to lay the smackdown, VW! Vacuums are serious business!
Rob, your comment sounds almost mystical - does being deprived of sensory apparatus mean turning off your computer?
In retrospect, Nick, I could have worded that a little better - but at least I know now that you read my blog! My intent was not to lump you in with my most significant purchases, but rather to say I made up my mind you were a keeper rather quickly, with no research, and very little comparison shopping ;-)
DP, Yes, he's real - even someone as nutty as me would not create an imaginary blogging husband. I'd be more likely to invent something like a web-surfing pet rat.
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | April 28, 2009 at 06:36 PM
Very thought-provoking. I'm definitely a maximizer in most things, I love research. So here's my thought about why you can be impulsive about most things you buy, but not plants: could it be a matter of what you care about most?
On the other hand, I also have to say my maximizer tendencies disappear when I am among plants and books. Just can't have enough of them, even if they do have to be discarded from time to time.
So maybe caring a lot about something blurs the maximizer/satisficer line, because we have entered into an altered state?
Posted by: Pomona Belvedere | April 28, 2009 at 06:40 PM
Hi Pomona. Goody! I like to be psychoanalyzed. Sounds like you're saying I go all Maximizer when it comes to plants either because I care about them so much or because they alter my brain chemistry and I'm somehow drunk on gardening?
I like the second idea.
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | April 28, 2009 at 06:50 PM
Susan, I guess I'm a little schizophrenic in my tendencies, though a perfectionist streak in me would maybe push me towards the maximizer side of things. Plant shopping with me can be torture as I pace the aisles, looking for the perfect plant that probably doesn't exist. But sometimes something is just too cool to say no to, even if it wasn't on any mental list.
There does seem to be a correlation for me between the size of the plant and the amount of time I spend picking it. With a smallish garden space, I can't just go ripping out big shrubs and trees to try something different every weekend. I worry most about those kinds of decisions--the big structure issues, building the bones of a garden. The smaller plants aren't filler, but they're easier to move around and adjust.
Posted by: lostlandscape | April 28, 2009 at 09:24 PM
Can I be both, obsessive about trees and much more casual about perennials? The stakes are so much higher with trees. What was that self-help book title, Don't sweat the small stuff and it's all small stuff, (except for trees which get really big).
Posted by: ryan | April 28, 2009 at 10:06 PM
Jeepers...I can't decide which one I am? I aim to be a Satisfiser, but then a Maximiser sounds good too.
Oh...the decisions...
Posted by: Ross | April 29, 2009 at 07:39 AM
I think I'm a recovering maximizer. I used to want to check out all the options and then I would get so overwhelmed with choices that, well, I couldn't decide and NOTHING would happen. I'm learning to take the advice of friends and professionals. The fewer choices that are presented to me the happier I am. It's been sort of a blessing in the garden that I have problems with deer, gophers, moles, limited water and crummy soil - it really limits the choices!
Posted by: Michelle | April 29, 2009 at 09:31 AM
James and Ryan, You make a good point. I agonize over trees much more than other plants. My backyard is tiny with very little privacy from neighbors, so lots of my favorite trees don't fit (although that hasn't necessarily stopped me from trying to make them fit).
Ross, you captured it perfectly, LOL!
Michelle, although I agree wholeheartely with the idea that fewer options is often a good thing, this is definitely the first time I have heard deer, gophers, and moles combined in a sentence with "blessing in the garden".
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | April 29, 2009 at 11:46 AM
I am a satisficer most of the time, I just plopped a perennial (Geum, flames of passion) that had survived the winter inside a pot on my patio, into the ground. I chose the perfect spot... a yarrow didn't come back so there it went... in less than a minute. However, I did do a very fast web search for growing conditions, but trusted the first website.
I also married an anti-satisficer who is working hard to be less so and thus is becoming more happy. She just walked by and saw your post and gives a thumbs up to the book you mention.
Posted by: wayne | April 29, 2009 at 03:11 PM
Definitely a satisficer. There's only so perfect one can get a living creation like a garden, and I find the more I struggle for perfection, the more clients come up with something ugly (an escallonia whale! A cutesy elephant statue with an umbrella on top!) to stick in the middle of my perfect creation. Much better to have a carefree try at "very good" and enjoy the small changes here or there that we make.
Posted by: Genevieve | April 29, 2009 at 04:46 PM
Wayne, I love it! An anti-satisficer! All kidding aside, my husband the maximizer was also struck by the article, realizing that spending more time doesn't always mean you are happier with the final decision.
Genevieve, I hear you on the "interesting" garden ornament ideas clients sometimes come up with - although an elephant with an umbrella is a new one for me! I'm trying to be more clear with clients up front that a garden is a living, evolving entity, and including more photos in my portfolio that aren't necessarily styled to death and look a little more real.
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | April 29, 2009 at 07:47 PM
Oh PLEASE Garden Chick! We both know that your constant changing of "something" in your garden is because there are just WAY too many wonderful things to do with a garden than either one of us have room for. Well, honestly, nobody has enough room to do it all.
Which is why I keep experimenting with all the "stuff" out there for apartment dwellers with a balcony patio. I FEEL like I have nowhere to go with all these great ideas!
And meanwhile I "replant" this little section or that with something INSPIRING!
The key here is that everybody does not find a particular new combination of plants, a new approach, any of this all that "inspiring".
In short, what YOU do with your garden, or what I do with mine is about something outside of our basic "types" in this regard.
Posted by: Ninja Granny | May 04, 2009 at 07:26 PM