Then you'll just have to be a horrible warning."
This great Catherine Aird quote was brought to my attention courtesy of Mary Ellen Hunt, a garden writer who recently contacted me on a shrink the lawn article for the San Francisco Chronicle - or SF Chron as the cool kids call it.
So this quote is my inspiration to take you on a tour of my own little plot of earth. But first, some back story – last spring we had our fence replaced and the garden was pretty relentlessly trampled. I asked the contractor to try and save the climbing roses and apparently what he heard was, save only the climbing roses. How did I deal with this gardening disaster? Mostly by ignoring my back yard’s gardening chores all year.
Now that my self-serving excuses are out of the way, let’s begin the tour:
Good example: Carex pansa lawn substitute
I planted this low water lawn alternative last fall. It’s not growing very fast, but I’m hoping for a burst of speed and some greening up now that it’s had all winter to establish some roots. This photo is from when it was first planted as there's a giant shade stripe across the the front yard from the house this afternoon.On a side note, notice the lavender to the left? The sizes are even more mismatched now. When you plant a row of the same thing, why do they always grow at different rates?
Horrible warning: Lawn in the wrong place
My husband has been in denial for years about the fact that there is not enough sun for a lawn in this part of the garden. We’ve actually resodded three times but are finally facing reality. He’s not bothering to mow it anymore since we are starting a new garden project to replace this area in a few weeks (hint, it involves purple paint). I know, I’m excited, too.
Good example: ET controller
Last October, we switched out our traditional controller for a smart one that relies on weather station data magically beamed in every day to determine when and how much to water. Check out my earlier posts here and here if you want more info.
Horrible warning: Tree roots
These columnar ornamental pears are great for privacy screening in a narrow space, but the surface roots take over, making it extremely difficult to plant under. If you’re going to use them, plant your understory right away, and try to stick with your original choices, as replanting later is challenging. (Probably pointless advice, since how many gardeners plant an area only once? Snicker, snicker.)
Good example: Raised mounds
We mounded the soil and planted this Kangaroo Paw and Walker’s Low Catmint last spring. The extra drainage is really helping the plants thrive – everything will be blooming in a few weeks. It also allowed me to work around the stump left over from the London Plane Tree we removed a few years ago, a cheaper alternative to stump grinding.
Horrible warning: Messy patio tree
We chose this Brazilian Pepper 11 years ago before I knew much about plants. On the plus side it’s a great shade tree and evergreen, but on the downside, it drops litter all the time. Nick sweeps the patio almost daily in the summer. It's only tidy right now because he swept last evening. Oh well, at least the leaves cover the bird poop.
So as not to end this post with the words “bird poop”, I will say that publicly revealing the state of my garden is inspiring me to whip it into shape so I can stun you with some after photos. In the meantime, here’s a photo I took a few years ago, back in its glory days.
How about you - any good examples or horrible warnings to share?







![Dcp_4581_edited-tiltshift[1]](/a/6a00e553af986f883401156fc3f775970b-320wi.webp)















I like what you did in the front bed, not just because you lost the lawn, but because of the sense of balance and proportion you've achieved. Many such attempts get too busy, and although you have a lot of elements, they work well together. My only adjustment would be to move the larger variegate grass (Miscanthus?) closer to the yellow-green lower grasses. They're similar in color but different in form - two of a kind, so to speak. So rather than strand the Miscanthus, let it play with the other. I really like the mounding gray near the walkway. Good punctuation.
As for the Brazilian pepper, I recommend a controlled napalm drop. The plant is a blight. Thanks!
Posted by: Billy Goodnick | April 02, 2009 at 03:30 PM
BTW: Found your blog via your comment at GardenRant - that book cover design sucks rotten dinosaur eggs.
Posted by: Billy Goodnick | April 02, 2009 at 03:31 PM
Well, Billy isn't shy about his opinions, is he? In case he checks back - you're also pretty entertaining, Billy, which I think is your objective :-)
I loved the tour of your yard, Susan. Exposing our successes and 'projects-in-waiting' (failures fall into this category) are a fun part of blogging.
As you already know, my yard is one huge project-in-waiting. I feel better about my haphazard planting beds in the backyard since giving the area an official name: Plant Evaluation and Propagation Area (PEPA). I hope buying one of this and one of that now will help me make wise decisions later when I want a bunch of this and a bunch of that to create large, coordinated swathes of color in the beds we'll eventually cut from the lawn.
And if all our projects were done already, what would we do with ourselves?
Posted by: VW | April 02, 2009 at 05:54 PM
Ha, talk about publicly revealing the state of your garden. Last year I had 285 people come for the going native garden tour (www.gngt.org). I expect more this year. But I digress.
I find my best decisions have also been the most questionable. We filled the pool shortly after we bought the house (great idea!) but now find it's possible to convert your pool into a cistern (wish we hadn't filled it, sort of). I sowed California poppies the first year (great idea! so cheerful, no water) but they reseed like crazy (I pull a lot). I made a pretty oak barrel water feature (great idea!) but now I'm getting raccoons (don't get me started)...
Posted by: Renate (Town Mouse) | April 02, 2009 at 08:03 PM
When I first read that Catherine Aird quote, many years ago, I was going to frame it. Instead, I live it.
Here's a horrible warning, from a long list: Don't buy and plant a whole lot of full sun plants within three feet of the edge of the shade from a redbud. I thought the redbud was done growing. Now I have 1) a bigger redbud, 2) a shade garden, and 3) many dead, full sun plants.
Posted by: DaffodilPlanter | April 02, 2009 at 08:28 PM
What is it with husbands and lawns? Yay to your front yard reduction. I have zero experience with Carex pansa, but based on what I've seen the sedges in your space should be gorgeous before too long. You've got me wondering big time with your purple paint comment...
I also like how dealing with a tree trunk you didn't want to have ground up led you to a cool solution. We had a tree taken out 10 years ago but didn't want to pay double to get the stump ground out. So the tree guy cut it off at about two feet and notched a little planter in its center. It's turned out to be the greatest place to plant bromeliads. Sometimes living with a compromise pushes you to even better solutions.
Posted by: lostlandscape | April 02, 2009 at 09:10 PM
LOL, the drip system in my "garden" is an example of how not to lay one out. Drip emitters dripping onto the crowns of plants, lines buried so deep that you can't find one until you pierce it with a shovel, main lines laid directly under plants. . .
I inherited this mess from a previous gardener and I curse them every time I work on it.
And, as for the plantings, I'm still in rip out that mess mode.
Posted by: Michelle | April 03, 2009 at 09:02 AM
My goodness, Billy, you don't hold back. The miscanthus is actually a Cream Delight Phormium and at the rate the Japanese Forest Grass is spreading, they will soon be next to each other with no additional help from me.
VW, love the PEPA idea; very official. Does one require a special pass to access this, or is it open to all visitors?
Townie, we're so hard on our own gardens. When I visit someone's garden, they never start directing my attention to the 90% of it that is lovely, but immediately point out the two or three things that aren't working out.
DP, But dead plants add such lovely brown contrast to the garden! (At least that's what I tell clients when, ahem, some of my plant choices don't make the grade)
James, and the hilarious part about the lawn is, it's so small that you basically just set the mower on it, turn it on, and the whole thing is mowed. Very creative idea on the tree stump - I'd love to see a photo on your blog.
Michelle, I've decided not to count the drip system, because as you inherited it, it was someone else's horrible warning. You will have to return and confess to a personal sin!
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | April 03, 2009 at 09:41 AM
I think there should be a regular posting on the GE/HW
theme. I don't like to get unbalanced opinions that just focus on the HW side of things, but then at the same time, an overload of GE's makes me feel inadequate and surly. This post was just right, and real.
As I watered my flawed and beloved garden this morning (yeah, my HW is the fact that I was smart enough to *lay* the techline irrigation tubing, but too lazy to actually hook it up to a valve, and then got too excited about planting, and now I can't ever hook things up because there are too many plants!), I thought about what it would be like if I had to photograph everything for a magazine with an hour's notice.
The result would be a real photo of a real garden with all of its triumphs and tragedies. Gardens, like people, need to be loved for themselves, just as they are. Otherwise we deny the truth and humanity in ourselves, and the savage and uncooperative gorgeousness of nature. So I say bring it all on, the GE's and HW's, and embrace the imperfection.
Thanks for a great post, Susan!
Posted by: Plantanista | April 04, 2009 at 12:18 PM
Helpful post.
I'm not the best at garden design.
Not sure why...
Thanks,
patsi
Posted by: Patsi | April 04, 2009 at 03:01 PM
Plantanista, wonderful comment - thoughtful and well expressed. But if I ever do have a brief, shining moment with a garden full of good examples and nary a horrible warning in sight, get ready for the braggiest post you've ever read!
Patsi, glad you enjoyed the post!
Posted by: Susan (garden chick) | April 05, 2009 at 02:13 PM
Hi Susan! I love this post -- I'm so glad the Aird quote inspired such a great(and entertaining!) tour of your garden -- thanks for sharing this!!
Posted by: Mary Ellen | April 14, 2009 at 02:40 PM
Great post. My partner says he loves the lawn (and has promised to be the one to mow it, but rarely does). I am taking the turf off, sort of inch by inch, and Mr is sulking everytime he finds out. Perhaps I should shade it, in secret, and just make it disappear by itself...
Posted by: Camellia | April 14, 2009 at 03:56 PM
What would be a good groundcover to use as a lawn substitute? I'd like to use it in my front lawn so I don't have to mow it. I'd like something that grows no more than and inch or two high and is evergreen in Zone 7. It'll get full sun all day, too.
Posted by: generic viagra | March 23, 2010 at 01:14 PM