Since I've become a regular visitor to fellow gardener's blogs, I've noticed a subtle prejudice against garden design - as if somehow a garden that begins on paper instead of beginning with a carload of impulse buys from the nursery lacks a true soul. I've read posts where bloggers "confess" to designing parts of their gardens, like it's a dirty little secret. Now, unless the design includes a marijuana patch or a cockfighting arena, I'm not sure where this taboo comes from.
I'm as guilty as the next person of the throw-it-in-the-wagon-I'll-figure-out-where-to-plant-it-when-I-get home approach to garden design (actual planting optional, Troy, the snowberry bush I bought from you in November continues to wilt sadly in its pot while it waits for a permanent home), but when planning a major rennovation on a garden, taking some time to plan at least part of it can really pay off.
Here is a plan I completed for a client two weeks ago.
I've greyed out the plants so that you can see the whole plan (the client and contractor actually get multiple design pages with extensive notes - this is a simplified version) This project is very typical of what I have been doing lately - a client who wants to replace 100% of the lawn with low water plants. This is a much harder process to accomplish sans plan than when you have a traditional layout of lawn complemented by a few shrubs and flowers. Without a plan it is too easy to create a jumbled mess that overwhelms the house and does not increase your popularity with the neighbors.
To complement the peach colored house and purplish-grey tile the homeowner chose to retile his entryway, I developed a palette of dark green, light green, dark purple and silver foliage complemented by lavender and peach colored blooms - with a little red and orange thrown in. Additional texture and movement comes from a variety of Pennesetum cultivars (fountain grass).
Some of the specific plants in this plan:
Acacia baleyanna 'Purpurea" - beautiful evergreen tree with purple-tipped, silver/blue foliage.
Teucrium fruitcans 'Azure" for year round structure, foliage contrast and beautiful blue flowers in winter - photo courtesy of Gardensoft
Salvia leucantha, which along with lantana and bouganvillea was chosen by the client - photo courtesy of Gardensoft
Phormium 'Dark Delight' - will really pop the other colors as well as the tile and is great for year round color and architectural interest
Helianthemum - a hard worker in dry gardens
Pennisetum, my favorite fountain grass, compact and delicate - photo courtesy of Gardensoft
Amber Carpet Rose. This isn't available yet, but is a new introduction slated for 2009. I love carpet roses as they are low maintenance, drought tolerant, disease resistant, repeat blooming and compact and am thrilled they will be available in a peach color, which is my favorite coor in the garden.
I think I wandered from the original topic a bit, but my point is that a little space planning and color selection up front doesn't kill creativity, it lets you work out your issues on paper - which is much less expensive and time consuming that in the garden. So, fellow garden bloggers, have I changed anyone's mind?
























You never needed to change mine. :) I'd happily own up to "designing" my own garden if I knew the first thing about it. But it makes perfect sense to me that if one were going to spend any amount of money on landscaping, that they plan it out on paper beforehand, especially (she says, speaking form her limited experience) for things such as spacing. A plant with a 3' spread really *won't* fit in a tiny corner. ;-)
Posted by: Nancy Bond | January 09, 2009 at 01:12 PM
I try to plan out my beds, but most of the time the gardens at my house are not put in all at once and so they change and I have to adapt. Oftentimes what I map on paper does not work when out in the garden, so things change. Maybe many gardeners are a piecemeal gardener as I am meaning plans change and we work as we are able to with what we have. It is totally nothing personal against the design side of gardens which is really a smart way to garden. There are bloggers who do a great job of planning-oh how I admire them. Your plans look splendid.
Posted by: tina | January 09, 2009 at 02:44 PM
Hi Nancy and Tina - you're both being so nice! I was expecting some snarling purists telling me where I could stick my garden plans.
You're right, Nancy, it's very challenging to do a big space without a plan, but in the case of a 3' plant in a tiny corner, I confess to being guilty of wishful thinking myself on occasion, and trying to put too many plants into a small space. And even if you choose correctly, the little darlings don't necessarily obey! (Didn't they read the plan?)
Tina,spot on that a garden is a living organism, constantly in a state of transition. I usually stay involved with the installations on the gardens I design and particularly like to place the plants as I always rearrange them somewhat from the original design. I tell the contractor to factor in at least one additional trip to the nursery, because I know I am going to want to do some adding and subtracting. These are always my favorite gardens, because there's no substitute for actually being in the garden.
Posted by: susan (garden-chick) | January 09, 2009 at 03:54 PM
Shove your plans where the sun don't shine!
Only joking. I have to say it is the smart way to go about things. The truth is it is actually quite difficult to do. That said, It perhaps has to be the only way to arrive at an accurate budget.
The Pennisetum is stunning by the way.
Posted by: Rob (our French garden) | January 10, 2009 at 05:12 AM
Hi again, I don't think folks would be mad about what you said (except Rob of course-who we know is only joking and me too:) We all probably wish we had the talent to design, but it can be a difficult thing.
Thank you so much for the suggestion of Sarcococca ruscifolia (Sweetbox). It is on my must have list because it does grow here and grows in shade too. I will look for it this year and plant it in honor of you.
Posted by: tina | January 10, 2009 at 09:17 AM
I couldn't imagine tackling a big project without at least a basic structure. Moving from the traditional lawn with foundation plantings to something else, where the focus is more in the center of the yard, is a complete rethinking of how traditional yards were put designed. My guess is that home gardeners might equate working from a plan with building a kit model--Like, where's the room for self-expression? But if the gardener at least works towards developing good bones, the rest of the project can evolve over time and still look good.
Posted by: James | January 10, 2009 at 09:29 AM
Rob,
I'm realizing I'm going to have to try harder if I want to stir up some Gardenrant style controversy.
Tina, in some ways it is easier to be a professional designer of other people's gardens than your own. When I'm talking to clients about how to lay out hardscape, what to plant, etc. I have total confidence in my ideas and easily slide into an obnoxious self-congratulatory mode. Conversely, I'm often completely torn over what to do in my own garden, adding random plants because they caught my eye at a plant sale or a fellow designer mentions them, and have planted and replanted portions of my front and rear gardens at least 4 times. I guess the lesson is an outsider can sometimes offer the tough love and decisiveness we can't seem to manage in our own little plots.
Posted by: Susan (garden-chick) | January 10, 2009 at 09:42 AM
I wonder if many of us wish we could plan and thus we mock what we don't understand. So with that said, I am going to plan out a garden. The admissions dept at my school has relocated and they want my students and I to do some beautification.
as with most everything in life the middle road may be best here... some planning some stumbling in the dark.
You have inspired me to sign up for some garden design workshops held at the Morris Arboretum. will blog about that at some point.
Posted by: Wayne Stratz | January 11, 2009 at 05:43 AM
James, - you are right that when a garden project invoices something drastic like completely replacing a front lawn, it is almost impossible to do without some type of plan on paper. Doesn't have to be by a professional, a simple sketch is a good starting point. Speaking for myself, on one hand I find this type of design very rewarding, because I know I am contributing to a healthier, happier environment and also promoting the idea that non-traditional sustainable design can be beautiful.
On the other hand, this type of design is very difficult. I feel I'm getting better at it, but a lawn provides a nice restful negative space - the most basic of garden unifiers - so not only is this forcing me to develop new design strategies, but I find it much harder to hold all the images in my head.
Wayne - always love hearing from you and enjoy your open-minded approach, as well as the zen-like middle road emphasis. I've mentioned before that my most successful projects have occured when the client keeps me involved in the process and we make changes and adjustments along the way, so I agree a design is only the beginning of a garden. Looking forward to hearing about your design adventures.
Posted by: Susan (garden-chick) | January 11, 2009 at 10:36 AM
Great post Susan! I don't blog enough to have detected the bias, but i'll take your word for it.
As a fellow designer, of course, i am in complete agreement with you.
Your plans are impressive and the plants you showed in that design are wonderful, esp the Teucrium!
Posted by: Anne | January 12, 2009 at 09:28 AM
My mom's front garden was designed by a professional landscape designer. It is one of the loviest gardens I know...perfect for her house! When it came to her back garden my sis and I took a note from the designers book and sketched everything out, hardscape, plant material, everything before we even began. It turned out even better than we had hoped. It is due in large part to our pre-planning. So I love garden designs and designers alike! Great post, Kim
Posted by: inadvertentfarmer | January 12, 2009 at 09:45 AM
actually I am an anglo-catholic catholic (well that is what a Baptist once called me) with some zen like thoughts floating about, who was raised Lutheran. made rosemary bread all day with my students. Life is good no matter how you look at it.
Posted by: wayne stratz | January 12, 2009 at 12:49 PM
Anne - if you are a Teucrium fan, you might like Westringia fruticosa 'Jervis Gem' or 'Smokey', which a fellow designer recently turned me on to. Looking at the lovely photos on your website, I get the feeling that like me you are often dealing with smaller beds where teucrium gets too big. These cultivars aren't as bright of a silver but they stay in the 2-3' range, are low water and evergreen.
Kim, an experience like yours is what made me realize I wanted to be a designer in the first place. I worked with a professional on my own backyard around 10 years ago, and her ability to take my general ideas and turn them into a workable sketch seemed like magic to me. My thought is, you need a plan because, otherwise, what are you going to deviate from?
Wayne, regardless of which of your varied religious perspectives you are channeling on any given day, your funny, insightful comments are always welcome.
Posted by: Susan (garden-chick) | January 12, 2009 at 05:24 PM
Susan, that is just about the best quote I've heard this year...
"My thought is, you need a plan because, otherwise, what are you going to deviate from?"...just perfect! Mind it I use that in my words to live by section? I will give you credit of course, Kim
Posted by: inadvertentfarmer | January 13, 2009 at 04:28 PM
Feel free, Kim! (and I was only halfway joking.) Susan
Posted by: susan (garden-chick) | January 13, 2009 at 06:47 PM
There is nothing wrong with a plan, on paper or in your head! For me personally, I lack the income to purchase plants en masse and tend to get them here and there as divisions, on sale, whatever. The point being, I can not personally make a design for that ahead of time because I never have all the plants at once, or know what they're even going to be. I have created gardens for three others, who were in a position to acquire all plants at once, and that was just as fun, ina different way.
Posted by: Monica | January 16, 2009 at 04:01 PM
Monica, you're right, people generally don't need a plan unless they are moving into a new, completely unlandscaped home or doing a major overhaul. Doing it a little bit a time is fun because you can add little treasures here and there as you find them, and the scope is not as overwhelming. On the other hand, as you've discovered, it is really fun to create an entire garden in one fell swoop. Kind of like gutting and remodeling a room instead of decorating overtime.
Posted by: susan (garden-chick) | January 17, 2009 at 05:22 PM
Billy (Garden Wise Guy), and I were just commenting on how few blogs there are that look at gardening from a design point of view.
I'm glad I stumbled onto your blog - mind if I hang around a bit...?
Posted by: Ross | February 13, 2009 at 03:55 AM
Hi Ross!
I love visits from other designers! Took a quick peak at your blog, and wouldn't be surprised to learn we are working with a lot of the same plants and design ideas, despite our geographic distance. I'll drop by for a longer visit later (and will have to find out who the Garden Wise Guy is), but have just about used up my 1/2 your alotted to blogging this morning.
Posted by: susan (garden-chick) | February 13, 2009 at 08:26 AM
I'm probably one of the guilty parties, having referred to some outdoor-designers "landscrapers." When I've used that term, it's usually in reference to designers attached to firms that design outdoor kitchens, patios, fountains and the like - where plantings are incidental. Most of these folks show up at the local garden show exhibiting their creativity in gas grills, outdoor bars and refrigerators. I'm all for planning and especially design - I'm a graphic designer – and feel that no one should start a garden by plopping. Not that that's the worst way to start either!
Posted by: Jim/ArtofGardening.org | May 04, 2009 at 10:35 AM
Susan, I've noticed the same anti-design prejudice on GardenRant - both in posts and in comments - and do my best to combat it. Even diehard gardeners benefit from design help, if they have an open mind. Just my 2 cents. S
Posted by: Susan Harris | June 08, 2009 at 11:26 AM